Goodreads review link

★★★★★ 4.75/5

I received a copy of this book on Netgalley in exchange for an honest review.

Massive and expansive but surprisingly focused space opera. This takes the build up of Archimedes Engine and runs with it beautifully. It is a masterfully plotted adventure that takes the many threads built up over the series and weaves them together in an intricate and satisfying way while leaving plenty on the table to explore in the future.

From the get-go we’re picking up where Archimedes Engine left off and we get immediate payoff from what it set up in awe inspiring and, often terrifying, moments.

I don’t think I can emphasize enough how good the politics are. The many different factions, their motivations, their hidden schemes, and the dynamic nature of the alliances that form and break over the story is seriously impressive, it has to be some of my favorite politics in fiction.

It makes it fairly complex to keep track of, but it is very rewarding and engaging and made the world feel real and deep. It also makes the plot extremely compelling, as I was constantly thinking about what was going to happen and how these various factions might interact and conflict with each other. Often the characters involved are very long-lived so these Great Games they’ve been playing have been set up for millennia.

The world building is impressive and well thought out. It’s clear Hamilton put a lot of legwork into the world and he is disciplined enough to maintain focus on telling the story he set out to tell in a way that reasonably wraps up in the 1600 or so page budget for the duology.

While this is by no means a short story, if anything, I think this could have been a 5+ book series and in a lot of ways it could have benefitted from a bigger page count, but I do appreciate that we weren’t left waiting for years and years for the resolution to the story. So while I do want more, I am satisfied with what I’ve read so far and will be thinking of this world for quite some time to come.

Some of the plot points resolve a bit too quickly, it needed some breathing room after big climactic moments. In some ways some of the big confrontations resolve a bit too easily but it keeps the story moving and we don’t get hung up on any particular plotline. This makes some of the moments with the characters not hit as hard as I think they could have, it’s sort of a tradeoff for a faster moving plot and the consequence is we don’t connect with the characters as much and don’t have as much of an emotional connection with them.

I do think Hamilton could have added some more pages to make these moments a bit harder hitting when they happen but I was able to connect some of the dots in my head to put myself in the shoes of the characters, but it’s definitely not the focus for the story. This is consistent with other Hamilton series so I’m not surprised but it could have been an area of improvement.

One of the technologies is used as a bit of a crutch multiple times (3 times that I remember) and in very similar ways to give insight into the antagonist factions without having as much at stake. This particular technology is a pretty interesting idea, I’m just not sure the implications of it were explored fully and it was a pretty convenient plot device at times, it wasn’t a deal breaker for me however.

I do think the plot felt like you could tell it was set up to play out a particular way at times and could have been a little more dynamic and messy, but there were also plenty of surprises along the way, so not that big of a negative against the series.

Overall this is one of my favorite space operas and one of my favorite reads of this year. Really looking forward to the video game and hope it lives up to the story and world in the books.